Change is on the horizon for the trucking industry, and it’s coming fast. The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) is rolling out a significant overhaul of its Safety Measurement System (SMS)—the framework that shapes Compliance, Safety, Accountability (CSA) scores. Whether you’re a small fleet owner, a safety manager for a large carrier, or somewhere in between, these changes will impact how your company is evaluated and prioritized for enforcement.
This isn’t just a minor tweak. FMCSA is rethinking how motor carriers are compared, scored, and flagged for safety concerns. Let’s unpack what’s changing, why it matters, and how you can stay ahead of the curve.
CSA Scores: The Backbone of Safety Compliance
CSA scores are the trucking industry’s report card, calculated from data collected through:
- Roadside inspections,
- Crash reports,
- And violation records.
The FMCSA uses these scores to identify high-risk carriers and focus enforcement where it’s needed most. However, the system has faced criticism for being overly complicated and sometimes inequitable. Small carriers often felt penalized unfairly, while others questioned whether CSA scores truly reflected safety performance.
FMCSA heard the feedback loud and clear. The revamped SMS is designed to simplify scoring, level the playing field, and make the system more transparent.
FMCSA’s SMS Overhaul: What’s Changing?
After receiving industry feedback on its 2023 proposal, FMCSA has finalized the updates to the SMS. Here’s what’s new:
1. BASICs Become Compliance Categories
The SMS’s Behavior Analysis and Safety Improvement Categories (BASICs) are getting a much-needed rebranding as Compliance Categories. Why? Because no one could remember what BASICs stood for, and the name didn’t clearly reflect its purpose.
Here’s how FMCSA is reorganizing these categories:
- The Unsafe Driving category now includes violations related to controlled substances, alcohol, and operating while out-of-service. Grouping these violations together streamlines enforcement and focuses on driver behavior.
- Vehicle Maintenance is being split into two new categories:
- Vehicle Maintenance: Driver Observed focuses on violations drivers should identify during pre- and post-trip inspections.
- Vehicle Maintenance captures issues that require a mechanic’s expertise.
This change ensures drivers aren’t penalized for violations beyond their control.
2. Simplified Scoring System
Currently, violations are assigned severity weights from 1 to 10, based on their perceived risk. While this system made sense on paper, in practice, it led to confusion and inconsistent scoring.
The revamped SMS simplifies scoring to a binary system:
- Violations are now weighted as either 1 or 2.
- Severe infractions, like out-of-service violations, carry a weight of 2.
- Less critical issues are assigned a weight of 1.
This change makes the system more transparent and easier to understand.
3. Focus on Recent Violations
Under the old SMS, violations from years ago could still drag down a carrier’s score. That’s changing. FMCSA will now focus on violations from the past 12 months, giving carriers a fresh chance to improve their safety record.
This shift rewards carriers for maintaining strong safety practices and ensures scores reflect current performance rather than outdated mistakes.
4. Fair Comparisons with Proportionate Percentiles
One of the most controversial aspects of the old SMS was its grouping system, which categorized carriers into “safety event groups” based on inspection frequency. This often led to unfair comparisons, particularly for smaller carriers.
FMCSA is replacing this with proportionate percentiles, which ensure carriers are compared to others with similar operational scopes. For example:
- A small carrier with only a few inspections won’t be unfairly pitted against a mega fleet with thousands of inspections.
- Instead, comparisons will account for the scale and nature of each carrier’s operations.
This is a win for small carriers, who often felt disadvantaged under the old system.
5. Consolidating Violations into Groups
FMCSA is simplifying how violations are categorized. The current system includes 959 specific roadside violations, which will now be consolidated into 116 broader categories. This makes it easier for carriers and enforcement officials to focus on patterns of non-compliance rather than isolated incidents.
6. Adjusted Utilization Factor
The Utilization Factor, which accounts for vehicle miles traveled (VMT) in scoring, is getting a modern upgrade. FMCSA is increasing the mileage cap from 200,000 to 250,000 miles per power unit. This change reflects the realities of today’s trucking industry, where longer routes are common.
Why These Changes Are Necessary
The SMS was first introduced in 2010 as part of the CSA program, aiming to improve safety by identifying high-risk carriers. While the concept was solid, execution wasn’t perfect. Industry stakeholders raised concerns about:
- The complexity of the scoring system,
- Unfair comparisons between carriers of different sizes,
- And the lack of transparency.
In 2017, Congress ordered FMCSA to commission an independent review of SMS. Researchers recommended adopting Item Response Theory (IRT), a sophisticated statistical model. However, FMCSA ultimately rejected IRT for being too complex, opting instead to refine the existing system based on industry feedback.
These updates reflect a careful balance between simplicity, fairness, and effectiveness.
Industry Reaction
The industry’s response to the proposed changes has been largely positive. Here’s what stakeholders are saying:
- Simplified Scoring: Carriers appreciate the clarity of the new 1 or 2 system, which eliminates the ambiguity of the old 1-to-10 scale.
- Focus on Recent Data: Most agree this provides a fairer snapshot of current safety performance, rewarding carriers that have made improvements.
- Fairer Comparisons: Small carriers, in particular, are thrilled about the move to proportionate percentiles, which levels the playing field.
However, there are some concerns. Critics worry that simplifying severity weights might dilute the importance of certain violations, like drug and alcohol infractions. FMCSA has acknowledged these concerns but believes the overall benefits outweigh the risks.
How to Prepare for the New SMS
FMCSA hasn’t announced an official launch date for the revamped SMS, but carriers should use this time to prepare. Here’s how:
1. Visit the Preview Site
FMCSA has created a preview site where carriers can see how their scores might change under the new system. Use this tool to identify areas that need improvement and start addressing them now.
2. Conduct Internal Audits
Review your safety practices and focus on areas that frequently result in violations. Pay special attention to:
- Driver behavior,
- Vehicle maintenance,
- And recordkeeping for hours of service (HOS) compliance.
3. Train Your Team
Educate your drivers, mechanics, and safety personnel about the changes. The more they understand the new system, the better equipped they’ll be to maintain compliance.
4. Stay Informed
FMCSA plans to host webinars and release guidance materials in the coming months. Keep an eye on their official SMS page for updates.
Why It Matters
The SMS overhaul isn’t just about numbers on a spreadsheet—it’s about safety, fairness, and the future of the trucking industry. By focusing on recent violations, simplifying scoring, and creating fairer comparisons, FMCSA is giving carriers an opportunity to improve their operations and rebuild their reputations.
For carriers, this is a chance to reset. The new system rewards proactive safety management, making it easier to maintain compliance and avoid costly interventions.
Gain exclusive access to our CDL & DOT Compliance articles with a trial at DOTDocs.com. And don’t forget to claim your FREE micro audit at THE ECLIPSE DOT MICRO AUDIT. Ready for seamless operations? Discover the difference today!
Sources
- FMCSA Safety Measurement System Overview: csa.fmcsa.dot.govcsa.fmcsa.dot.gov
- Detailed Overview of SMS Changes: FMCSA Official PDF
- Analysis of SMS Adjustments: Landline Media
- FMCSA Federal Register Notice: Enhanced Carrier Safety Measurement System (SMS)